SOUTH FLAG LAKE, INC. V. GORDON 138 Cite as 374 Ark. 138 (2008) [374 SOUTH FLAG LAKE, INC. v. Henrietta GORDON, et al. 08-623 286 S.W3d 146 Supreme Court of Arkansas Opinion delivered June 26, 2008 APPEAL & ERROR — CIRCUIT COURT'S ORDER DID NOT COMPLY WITH RULE 5(b) — REMANDED FOR COMPLIANCE. — The supreme court has held that it expects strict compliance with the requirements of Rule 5(b) of the Arkansas Rules of Appellate Procedure–Civil; where an order fails to comply with Rule 5(b), the supreme court may remand the matter to the circuit court for compliance with the rule; here, because the circuit court's order failed to strictly comply with Rule 5(b)(1), the matter was remanded to the circuit court for compliance. Motion for Rule on Clerk; remanded.
SOUTH FLAG LAKE, INC. V. GORDON ARK.] Cite as 374 Ark. 138 (2008) 139 John P. Verkamp, for appellant. No response. ER CURIAM. Appellant South Flag Lake, Inc., by and p through its attorney, John P. Verkamp, has filed a motion for rule on clerk. On January 17, 2008, the circuit court entered an order extending appellant's time to file the transcript on appeal until May 23, 2008. Appellant states that when it attempted to tender the record to this court's clerk on May 22, 2008, the clerk declined to docket the record due to lack of compliance with Rule 5(b)(1)(C) of the Arkansas Rules of Appellate Procedure—Civil. The circuit court's January 17, 2008 order states that "Nile Defendant does not object to the Plaintiff's request for extension of time," but fails to specifically state that all parties had the opportunity to be heard on the motion. South Flag Lake, Inc. argues that the circuit court could not have had knowledge of Gordon's position regarding the motion unless it had heard from Gordon and that Gordon, therefore, must have had the opportunity to be heard. Arkansas Rule of Appellate Procedure—Civil 5(b)(1) provides: (b) Extension of Time. (1) If any party has designated stenographically reported material for inclusion in the record on appeal, the circuit court, by order entered before expiration of the period prescribed by subdivision (a) of this rule or a prior extension order, may extend the time for filing the record only if it makes the following findings: (C) All parties have had the opportunity to be heard on the motion, either at a hearing or by responding in writing; Ark. R. App. P.—Civ. 5(b)(1) (2008). This court has held that it expects strict compliance with the requirements of Rule 5(b) and that it does not view the granting of an extension as a mere formality See, e.g., Winrock Grass Farm, Inc. v. Metropolitan Nat'l Bank, 373 Ark. 515, 517, 284 S.W.3d 521, 522
SOUTH FLAG LAKE, INC. V. GORDON 140 Cite as 374 Ark. 138 (2008) [374 (2008); Kelly v. Ford, 373 Ark. 111, 112, 281 S.W.3d 744, 745 (2008); Lancaster v. Carter, 372 Ark. 181, 182, 271 S.W.3d 522, 523 (2008); Studie v. Corbin, 369 Ark. 209, 210, 252 S.W.3d 136, 137 (2008). The language in the circuit court's January 17, 2008 order fails to specifically state that all parties had the opportunity to be heard on the motion at a hearing or by responding in writing. Therefore, it fails to strictly comply with Rule 5(b)(1). Where an order fails to comply with Rule 5(b), this court may remand the matter to the circuit court for compliance with the rule. See, e.g., Winrock Grass Farm, Inc., 373 Ark. at 517. Upon remand for compliance with Rule 5(b)(1), the circuit court is to determine whether the rule was complied with at the time the original motion for extension of time was filed and granted. Id. at 517. The circuit court should not permit the parties the opportunity to correct any deficiencies, but instead should make the findings required by the rule as if they were being made at the time of the original motion. Id. Should the requirements not have been met at the time of the initial motion for extension and order, the circuit court's order upon remand should so reflect and be returned to this court. Id. [1] Because the circuit court's order failed to strictly comply with Rule 5(b)(1) of the Arkansas Rules of Appellate Procedure—Civil, this matter is remanded to the circuit court for compliance. BROWN, J., not participating.
You are being directed to the most recent version of the statute which may not be the version considered at the time of the judgment.