Supreme Court

Decision Information

Decision Content

ARK.] 589 ARKANSAS STATE HOSPITAL v. ESTATE OF GRACE BROOKS CULVER, AN INCOMPETENT 5-4543 426 S. W. 2d 374 Opinion delivered April 15, 1968 APPEAL & ERROR-FINAL JUDGMENTS-REVIEW.-COUrt'S order allowing part of State Hospital's claim against incompetent's estate for maintenance and treatment for only 3 years of her confinement was a final judgment for it was not necessary that an express disallowance of the remainder of the claim accompany the order. Appeal from Randolph Probate Court, P. S. OM-ningham, Judge; reversed. Douglas Bradley, for appellant. George H. Steimel, for appellee. GEORGE ROSE SMITH, Justice. Since 1947 Grace Brooks Culver, a mentally incompetent woman, has been almost continuously confined to the State Hospital. In 1966 Mrs. Culver inherited $12,388.03, which was paid to her guardian. The State Hospital then filed a claim in the probate court against Mrs. Culver's estate for $16,268.74, which is shown to be the sum due the State Hospital for her maintenance and treatment during the years of her confinement, nothing having ever been paid upon the account. This appeal is from a probate court order allowing the claim for three years only, in the amount of $5,280. Counsel for the guardian concede, with candor, that there is no applicable statute of limitations with respect to the State Hospital's assertion of a claim of this kind. Cruce v. Ark. State Hospital, 241 Ark. 680, 409 S. W. 2d 342 (1966) ; Alcorn v. Ark. State Hospital, 236 Ark. 665, 367 S. W. 2d 737 (1963). In fact, counsel's only argument against a reversal is the forlorn suggestion
590 [244 that the court's order is not a final judgment, for the reason that the allowance of part of the State Hospital's claim was not accompanied by an express disallowance of the rest of it. Such a contention does not deserve serious discussion. Reversed and remanded for the entry of an order allowing the claim.
 You are being directed to the most recent version of the statute which may not be the version considered at the time of the judgment.