Supreme Court

Decision Information

Decision Content

ARK.] CITY OF MAGNOLIA V. KENDRICK. 1029 CITY OF MAGNOLIA V. KENDRICK. 5-1309 304 S. W. 2d 945 Opinion delivered June 17, 1957. [Rehearing denied Sept. 30, 1957] 1. MUNICIPAL CORPORATIONS SALARY ACTS, CONSTRUCTION.—Provision in Act 280 of 1951 that the salary of the municipal court clerk should be $2,400 per year but that the city council could fix the salary at any sum not exceeding $3,000 per annum or could designate some other officer of the city to perform the duties of such clerk, held not to prevent the city council from setting the salary of the clerk at a figure less than $2,400 per year. 2. STATUTESCLASSIFICATION BY POPULATION, CONSTRUCTION.—Provision in Act 313 of 1953 with reference to the county-seat towns with less than 2,400 population; held inapplicable to the city of Magnolia.
1030 CITY OF MAGNOLIA V. KENDRICK. [227 Appeal from Columbia Circuit Court, Second Division; Tom Marlin, Judge; reversed with directions. William I. Prewitt and Joe D. Woodard, for appellant. Henry B. Whitley, for appellee. SAM ROBINSON, Associate Justice. In 1951, the ap-pellee, J. W. Kendrick, was City Clerk of the City of Magnolia, and, as such, he was ex-officio Clerk of the Municipal Court. The City Council fixed his salary as Clerk of the Municipal Court as $1,800.00 per year ; by agreement, the city paid one-half of the salary and the County one-half. Kendrick contends that he should have been paid a salary of $2,400.00 per year as Clerk of the Municipal Court. He filed suits against the county and the city for the difference between the $1,800.00 per year and $2,400.00. The cases were consolidated ; demurrers to the complaints were overruled; the defendants elected to stand on the demurrers and refused to plead further. Judgment was rendered on the complaints and the county and city have appealed. Prior to 1951, Ark. Stats. § 22-713 provided : •"The Judge of the Municipal Court may appoint a Clerk for the court who shall be designated and known as the Municipal Court Clerk, and the salary of such clerk shall be $1,800.00 per annum, payable in equal Monthly installments. * * *; Provided, the city council of any city subject to this act may fix the salary of the Municipal Court Clerk at any sum not exceeding eighteen hundred dollars ($1,800.00) per annum, and may designate that the duties of such clerk be performed by any other officer of the city." The General Assembly of 1951 adopted Act 280, which amended the above statute by providing that the salary should be $2,400.00 per year, but that the city council could fix the salary at "any sum" not exceeding $3,000.00 per year. The 1953 General Assembly, by Act 313, amended the statute by adding the provision, "in county-seat towns with less than 2,400 population, the City Council may fix the salary of the clerk at any sum
ARK.] CITY OF MAGNOLIA v. KENDRICK. 1031 not to exceed eighteen hundred dollars ($1,800) per annum." Appellee . maintains that the 1951 amendment fixed the salary at $2,400.00 per year and that the city has no authority to pay less than that amount. We do not agr6e with the appellee in that respect. The 1951 amendment merely fixes the salary at $2,400.00 in the event the city does not elect to pay some other sum not exceeding $3,000.00 per year. The amendment clearly states: " * * Provided, the city council of any city subject to this Act may fix the salary of the Municipal Court Clerk at any sum not exceeding three thousand dollars ($3,000.00) per annum, and may designate that the duties of such clerk may be performed by any other officer of the city." Obviously, it was the intention of the General Assembly to permit the city to assign the duties of the Clerk of the Municipal Court to some officer of the city who was already drawing a salary from the city. The act permits the city to pay such officer an additional sum not exceeding $3,000.00, but considered as commensurate with the work that he would do as Clerk of the Municipal Court, which, as a matter of fact, might require very little of his time. To hold that the city could not pay an amount less than $2,400.00 as salary to one serving as Clerk of the Municipal Court would be to read out of the act the words : "any sum not exceeding three thousand dollars ($3,000.00) per annum." The 1953 amendment is not applicable the City of Magnolia is not within the classification of cities affected by that amendment. Reversed, with directions to sustain the demurrer.
 You are being directed to the most recent version of the statute which may not be the version considered at the time of the judgment.